The 30-Year Itch: Why Does Oppression of Science and the Arts Keep Coming Back? (And Why We Should Be Concerned Now)
1
34
0
We like to think history marches in a straight line, ever forward toward progress. Especially when it comes to science and the arts, those beacons of human ingenuity that seem destined to triumph over darkness. Yet, a nagging question persists: why does it feel like every few decades, roughly every 30 to 50 years, the forces of tyranny, oligarchy, racism, and fascism creep back into the mainstream?
If you've ever felt a sense of déjà vu watching current events unfold, you're not alone. History isn't a simple upward trajectory; it often moves in cycles, and understanding why these oppressive periods recur is crucial to preventing them.
Challenging the Narrative: It's Not Always a War on Science and Art
Our initial thought might be that science and art are constantly battling against oppressive regimes. While there are certainly historical examples of this (think of Galileo or the Nazi condemnation of "degenerate art") the relationship between power and these domains is more complex. In fact, throughout history, science and even the arts have sometimes found support within established authorities, particularly when they served the prevailing worldview or offered practical benefits. Opposition tends to arise when these fields challenge the existing order or dominant ideologies.
The Human Condition: Fertile Ground for Oppression
The cyclical nature of oppression isn't just about political shifts; it's deeply intertwined with the human condition itself. Several psychological and societal factors play a significant role:
The Appeal of the Strong Leader: In times of uncertainty or crisis, people often crave strong, decisive leadership. Authoritarian figures skillfully exploit this desire, presenting themselves as saviors who can restore order.
The Power of "Us vs. Them": Humans have a fundamental need for belonging. Oppressive movements thrive by creating a strong sense of in-group identity while demonizing "outsiders" as threats. This can be based on race, religion, nationality, or any other perceived difference.
Emotional Manipulation: Fear and anger are potent tools for those seeking power. Authoritarian leaders often amplify existing anxieties and direct public rage towards scapegoated groups.
Generational Amnesia: The hard-won lessons of the past can fade with time. Each new generation may lack direct experience with the dangers of unchecked power, making them potentially more susceptible to the allure of oppressive ideologies.
Economic and Social Instability: Periods of economic hardship, social unrest, or rapid social change create fertile ground for extremist ideologies. When people feel insecure or left behind, they may be drawn to simplistic solutions and scapegoats offered by authoritarian movements.
Weakening Democratic Institutions: When trust in democratic processes erodes, and institutions designed to provide checks and balances are undermined, the path to authoritarianism becomes smoother.
Echoes Through Time: A Recurring Pattern
The feeling that these cycles occur every 30 to 50 years isn't entirely unfounded. While not a rigid rule, history does show recurring patterns of authoritarian revivals following periods of liberalization. Social trends, including discrimination, also tend to ebb and flow, influenced by economic and political factors.
A Warning Sign: Recent Trends in the United States
In recent years, there have been concerning trends in the United States that echo historical patterns of oppression. The Trump administration, for example, has exhibited tendencies that have been described as authoritarian populism. These include the disparagement of democratic norms, attacks on the legitimacy of opponents and the media, and the cultivation of a strongman image.
Furthermore, the administration's relationship with science and the arts raised alarms. There were reports of the suppression of scientific information, particularly regarding climate change, and a chilling effect on artistic endeavors due to budget cuts and restrictions on funding related to diversity, equity, and inclusion. The disbanding of the President's Committee on the Arts and Humanities and attempts to defund the National Endowment for the Arts signaled a devaluation of the cultural sector. These actions mirror historical attempts by authoritarian regimes to control information and suppress dissenting voices in both science and the arts.
The Enduring Power of Science and Art
Despite these recurring challenges, the long-term trajectory often favors progress, driven by the inherent human desire for truth and creative expression. Science, with its commitment to evidence and reason, plays a vital role in dismantling false and harmful ideologies. The arts, in their diverse forms, provide a crucial platform for articulating experiences of oppression, challenging dominant narratives, and inspiring resistance.
Staying Vigilant: Breaking the Cycle
Understanding the cyclical nature of oppression and the factors that contribute to it is the first step in breaking the pattern. We must remain vigilant, fostering historical awareness and critical thinking to combat generational amnesia. Strengthening democratic institutions, addressing economic inequality, and promoting social cohesion are also crucial.
The recent trends in the United States serve as a stark reminder that the fight against oppression is not a relic of the past. We must actively resist any attempts to undermine democratic norms, suppress scientific inquiry, or stifle artistic expression. The enduring power of science and the arts lies in their ability to challenge the status quo, foster empathy, and inspire hope. By actively supporting and engaging with these fields, we can equip ourselves and future generations to recognize and resist the forces of oppression, ensuring that the long arc of history continues to bend towards justice.
